Good News or Bad News - China’s Economy 40% Smaller Than Previously Thought
The World Bank’s latest estimates for the global economy contained a stunner of a statistic: China accounts for just under 10% of the world’s total output — or about 40% smaller than thought.
At $5.3 trillion based on 2005 data, China’s economy is still No. 2. But it has considerably more ground to make up before passing the U.S. in absolute size — if, in fact, it should ever do so. Total world output in 2005 was $55 trillion. The U.S. produced $12.4 trillion of that — with a population only one-fourth the size of China’s.
…
World Bank statisticians got access to real data on China for the first time ever, and came away surprised. “The previous, less reliable, methods led to estimates (of China’s GDP) . . . 40% larger than the results of the new, improved methods and benchmark,” the World Bank report said.
This should be a lesson for those who take international statistics at face value. Anytime you’re off by 40%, it’s more than a rounding error. It’s a big mistake — largely China’s fault, since it wouldn’t let anyone accurately measure its economy before.
And this is of more than just statistical interest. It means, for instance, that there are likely more than 300 million Chinese who live below the World Bank’s $1-a-day poverty line — not the 100 million previously estimated.
This helps explain why China’s communist regime still cracks down hard on any manifestations of dissent — contrary to its PR of China as the land of perpetual economic boom. It knows how bad things really are in the undeveloped hinterlands.
It also calls into question China’s financial ability to support a massive military buildup to challenge the U.S. Dollarwise, the country just won’t have the money — at least not yet. And besides, it should be spending that money on development — not arms.
In a way this is bad news as many US companies are basing their growth on a “China strategy”. Essentially selling their product to a growing Chinese middle class. A middle class that isn’t anywhere near as big as previously thought. On the other hand this development actually stabilizes the far east. If these numbers are correct China isn’t really in a position to do anything about Taiwan and Japan remains the dominant economic power, which works out well for the US.
Similar Independent Sources posts:
- US Trade deficit down by 6.9% in 2007: This after hitting record levels for 5 straight years. The deficit with China was up 10.2% however. December 2007 - petroleum imports were more ...
- China Trade Talks Update: Following up on yesterday's post about the US/China Trade Talks, the Washington Post reports that there has already been some progress: The Chinese g ...
- Dollar News - Good or Bad?: The drop of the dollar has had its good and bad points - Bad- When I need to buy cheap lead laden Chinese toys for my nieces and nephews its more e ...
- Rising Chinese Inflation Being Exported Along With Brain Damage Inducing Lead Toys: Growing numbers of economists are sounding warnings that rising cost pressures and wages in China mean that it may be starting to export inflation. An ...
- Dollar plummets - Exports rise: WASHINGTON (AP) -- The U.S. trade deficit fell to the lowest level in 28 months as a falling dollar spurred U.S. exports to an all-time high. The defi ...










January 2nd, 2008 at 9:32 am
[…] Original post by Chad […]
January 2nd, 2008 at 9:09 pm
When our firm was looking to establish a presence in Asia, the only question that we needed to answer was: Which country has the cheapest hookers?
January 2nd, 2008 at 9:13 pm
This explains why Independent Sources’ traffic to China has been 40% below previous expectations.