Irony: Aged Writer Who Penned Gay Cowboy Film Says Oscar Voters Too Old and Too Out of Touch With “Larger Culture”
Annie Proulx who wrote the story that led to the film “Brokeback Mountain,” spewed sour grapes at the Academy of Motion Pictures for passing over her gay cowboy-themed movie in the best picture category. Instead of accepting the fact that the Academy considered “Crash” a better film; Proulx pointed the finger at aging, conservative Angeleno voters:
“We should have known conservative heffalump academy voters would have rather different ideas of what was stirring contemporary culture, Roughly 6,000 film industry voters, most in the Los Angeles area, many living cloistered lives behind wrought-iron gates or in deluxe rest-homes, out of touch not only with the shifting larger culture and the yeasty ferment that is America these days, but also out of touch with their own segregated city, decide which films are good.
Given her comments, it is likely that Proulx never even saw “Crash” and thus is unaware that it is hardly a geriatric conservative film. She also failed to note the irony of a 70-something year old attacking voters for both being too old (”living in rest homes”) and for missing a “larger culture” when her own film’s theme could hardly be described as such.
She wrote a niche book that a talented director turned into a commercial success and a Best Picture nominee. To most people, these would be a reasons to celebrate. To others a chance to attack everyone not in lock-step with them. Annie is clearly in the second (classless) group.
Also commenting: BrokebackBlokes: Ms. Proulx has, in this moment, become that which she beheld. And the world is a little uglier for it.”
tags: brokeback mountain
Similar Independent Sources posts:
- “Three men and a little slut”: I don't know why I find this photo so funny. Perhaps it's because the original film was so annoying. photo: Spicy Joke Note that the film is ...
- How About Gay Cowboy … Wizards?: "The controversial cowboy movie (Brokeback Mountain), which is rated R in part for its sexuality, also is hitting theaters at a time when filmmakers a ...
- Lindsay Lohan Gets Digital Breast Reduction: From Hollywood.com: In what may be the worst use of technology ever: Teen actress Lindsay Lohan's breasts have been digitally reduced for forthcomin ...
- Techies use Bayesian analysis to predict indie film results; hint: pass on films described as “riveting”: Which of the following two independent films is more likely to succeed? Film A: "An accomplished narrative about the complex journey of love and ro ...
- Tom Hayden: Don’t Disagree With Me If You’re Black: In the Huffington Post, Tom Hayden rationally counters arguments that the race-is-everything viewpoint of the film Crash is flawed: The Times' news ...










March 14th, 2006 at 9:40 am
Let it go Annie….BOTH films were worthy…az were others…
Truly,
George Clooney and Russell Crowe
March 14th, 2006 at 9:27 pm
Its just the typical rant from the left these days. It doesn’t matter if they are battling the right or other lefties, they don’t win because of other racist, out of touch, (fill in the blank)-phobic people.
Check out the “I (heart) Huckabees” movie. It really is a stupid movie until you view it from the concept of a bunch of lefties battling each other. That makes it somewhat amusing.