Yahoo Surpasses Google: Then Falters in Independent Sources Performance Test
From the Associated Press (SF Gate):
In a major expansion, Yahoo Inc. said Monday that its online search engine index now spans more than 20 billion Web documents and images, nearly double the material scanned by rival Google Inc.
Yahoo’s expansion doesn’t necessarily mean it produces more useful results than Google, which has long been considered the Internet’s most comprehensive database.
Given the importance of search relevancy, we subjected the four big search engines to the Independent Sources Keyword Challenge.
Each of the search engines below was given the phrase “Crisis in the Arctic.” The higher the ranking of Independent Sources coverage of the Dano-Canuck stand-off, the more relevant the results are to us. Here is what we found:
- Google Independent Sources #1 result
- MSN: Independent Sources #1 result
- Yahoo: Independent Sources #7 result
- Ask Jeeves: Independent Sources #1 result
With all of the search engines except Yahoo, Independent Sources was correctly returned as the #1 result.
Despite the fact that Denmark and Canada are squaring off over Hans Island creating a crisis that is unprecedented in that part of the Arctic, Yahoo’s 20+ billion pages didn’t rank this international crisis as high as they did the International Science Initiative in the Russian Arctic (ISIRA). Talk about missing the ball!
We understand that Yahoo is still perfecting their search technology and that it may get better as they continue work on it. Until then, however, we advise people against using Yahoo on topics of critical importance such as the possibility of war breaking out between two northern powerhouses.
Technorati: sem SEO Google Yahoo hans island crisis in the arctic
Similar Independent Sources posts:
- Hans Island Update: Danish Expeditionary Force Sets Sail: What's New: A Danish cutter headed for disputed Hans Island this week, and the ship's captain had these provocative words aimed straight at claims of ...
- We May Not Be Able To Project Military Power, But Our Ad Copy Will Make You Surrender!: First the gun, then the tank, nuclear weapons, and now ... Google ads? The AP reports: Canada and Denmark have taken their diplomatic tussle over a lu ...
- Sex, Politics, or Economics: What brings you to Independent Sources?: The search results that bring you to Independent Sources say a lot about both you our readers and us the writers. We decided to look at our traffic lo ...
- California’s Google-based Tax System Roars On: The San Francisco Chronicle says that what's good for Google's stock market value is good for California: California took in a record $11.3 billion in ...
- Mayor Sam in LA’s MSM: A quick shout out to fellow-BFL blogger Mayor Sam for catching a perfectly abled politician parking in a handicap space. Even better the story was pic ...

August 9th, 2005 at 9:37 am
Along with most of my fellow intellectuals, I search using mamma.com exclusively. Mamma utilizes patented Hegelian logic and omega string theory variables. Using your “crisis in the arctic” phrase, you came up 7th. Yahoo got it right. I’m not saying that Google is primitive, but their CTO was recently found in a cave scratching out images of wooly mammoths.
August 10th, 2005 at 12:38 pm
up on Google has plummetted in recent weeks. It may well be that I’ve just become irrelevent, but Yahoo has a much wider net. As for looking for things that are not my name? Seeing as how the world revolves around me, I’m not sure that’s relevent. [ source ] [0cmts]
August 12th, 2005 at 3:41 pm
Independent Sources prefers “wiki” search engines. When the results come back we modify them to suit our needs.
October 6th, 2005 at 11:14 pm
wat dieper op de materie ingaat is Charlene Li in haar blog. Zij deed onder meer een paar testjes, waaruit Google wat het aantal werkelijk getoonde resultaten betreft, met meer treffers te voorschijn kwam dan Yahoo!. Een andere testje werd gedaan door Independent Sources . Mijn eigen indruk is dat Google nog altijd groter is dan Yahoo!. In baseer die indruk op een testje dat ik zelf heb gedaan. Ziehier twaalf vragen die een zo laag resultaat opleveren dat (doorgaans) ook de laatste treffer nog kan worden bekeken.
June 11th, 2006 at 7:31 am
[...] Yahoo Surpasses Google: Then Falters in Independent Sources Performance Test
[Independent Sources] Despite the [...]